Amazon.com: Customer reviews: Mansions of Madness 2nd Edition (BASE GAME) | Horror Game | Mystery Board Game for Teens and Adults | Ages 14 and up | 1-5 Players | Average Playtime 2-3 hrs

Top positive review

This review is for newbies.

Reviewed in the United States on April 22, 2019

This game gets really great reviews, even for families with teens so I took the bait. My wife and I played with our 13 and 11 year old daughters last night. I will give you information that I would have found useful prior to my purchase of this game. We like to play popular games like Pandemic, and less popular but still fun like Stone Age. This game is a step up in complexity of rules for us.

We played the introduction game and it started real slow. Half of the blame is our learning curve. My heart sank as our daughters seemed really bored. I had the app running full screen on our lap top with the music playing. My wife was also not enthralled but was really being a great cheerleader. The pace of the game picks up and the game has a pretty steep learning curve so we adapted to the pattern of what to do and when to do it. I had read that you need to get to the objective and not go on a scavenger hunt. My wife loves treasure hunts so we explored everything. I just let it flow knowing we were probably doomed but we would go down with lots of cool stuff in our satchel.

With the universe crashing down near the end, my wife was trying to keep our girls engaged. she wanted to see the end. The girls perked up a lot. The game took some unexpected turns. You could tell that the app was changing up and also trying to force us to the showdown. This morning, the girls wanted a bit of a replay on how it all went down and were talking about it. We had to take some pauses in the game (two totaling about 45 minutes), which worked flawlessly, but that first intro game still took us 4 hours (including paused time). Maybe we are challenged. Those are the facts, now here are some of my opinions.

Ignore the carping about poor quality of the figures. They are not museum pieces, but they are fine and definitely get the idea across as to what you are dealing with. They are worthy of painting if you are a modeler. The app was great. It was almost like a real dungeon master (I used to play D&D some 35 years ago). I think that it was adapting to our play style, changing things for us, and guiding us to the grand finale. Even if it wasn't, isn't it great that it felt like a real person was monitoring our game and adapting the game to us instead of vice-versa? The game has a great mix of mystery, treasure hunt, puzzles, and battles. We all want to play that first scenario again and I predict that it will go by in about half the time. I give the game 7/10 so far, but that rating seemed to be rising fast for all of us as the game mechanics became more second nature. The set up phase had us all at 10/10, before it started to drag. I will plan to update this after a few more tries. The instruction booklets are great and I was able to answer most of about 20 questions within one minute. Some relatively detailed nuances required maybe two minutes to find. No unanswered questions so far.

Regarding expansions, we started with Recurring Nightmares and Suppressed Memories figure and tile sets. The investigator figures were the biggest hit from them so far. We liked the 16 new possible investigators and two of us used them. Can't comment yet on whether the additional room tiles and monsters (a LOT of them came with the sets) are worth it.

My wife adds that kids should get a pep talk at the beginning of the game that the first hour is not reflective of the overall game experience. The game required a solid hour of learning for us, even with having read the instructions first. It's not like Monopoly where you get in and learn and play your first game. This game appears that it will be on our playlist longer, but it requires a training period for us.

277 people found this helpful

Top critical review

Critical reviews›

R. Huffman

Very pricey experience

Reviewed in the United States on August 31, 2016

Disappointment in the Mansion

If anyone knows me, you'll know I am a huge Fantasy Flight Games fanboy. Just about every game I bought with a FF logo on it, has been "hell-o-fun" and worth just about every penny I spent on it.

When I first started in the Hobby Board Gaming world, I always wanted a copy of Mansions of Madness 1st Ed. But the lack of friends wanting to be DM and the "clunky" rules (some go so far as saying it had "bad rules") kept me from buying it.

Almost a week before GenCon 2016 got under way, Fantasy Flight announced their unveiling of a new Mansions of Madness (2nd Ed.). When I heard there would be an app on IOS taking care of all the details and GM-ing for the players I was instantly excited.

Fast forward to my birthday...
I scrapped the money together to afford the high price tag of this "beast-of-a-game". When I received it in the mail, I was greatly disappointed by the quality of the figures and the bases. Many of the bases had excessive flash and the figures looked like they were rushed into production with very little care given to the detailing. When you look at Fantasy Flight's quality on minis to games like Descent and Imperial Assault, you'll find almost half the amount of minis and much less quality as well in this new game. Also the plastic is very soft and fitting them into the very large black bases is quite an effort. The figures also have a tendency to not stay in the bases. Some of the bases are so large that they cover a large portion of the beautiful room tiles which is a little annoying to me. I understand the reason for the bases including the stats of the monster, but the app could of had those stats and then FF could of included simple round small bases which didn't interfere with the board.

There isn't much items to pick up or gather along the way. In other games like this, there are many items and gear you can add "buffing" your toon to help get through a scenario. I simply would of preferred... more. Also there are only 4 scenarios in the box and that is a crime. There should be double that amount of scenarios and again..... I would of preferred ... more.

Also the IOS DM app.... seems to do almost too much. I often felt like it was playing me. Leading into situations or into rooms... and when I didn't it punished me. Much like linear video games such as BioShock with a maze-like quality, I felt like I could not take the lead. Now many this is a bit harsh, but it is a real feeling I get from the app. I can see how DMs can alter the game for the players, because like in most RPGs like D&D, you tailor the game to your players. "Different strokes for different folks". I am not sure how MoM2ndEd could of done this, but this thought did cross my mind.

Also the app does not save longer scenarios.This glitch has many gamers frustrated, but with that said, Fantasy Flight will probably have this fixed soon. Also I have only heard one monster with a sound effect from the app. This caught me off guard and scared me a little. It also got me "bummed" that only one monster of this game had it's own sound effect.

The art on the room tiles, rules and game box are stunning though. Fantasy Flight in my mind always just amazes me with such spectacular eye catching imagery.

I should say that I do like the rules. Fantasy Flight has been doing rules books where there is a small booklet "how to play" leading you gently into game-play with an accompanying glossary booklet. This all works very well, but like FF XCOM app, they should of included a learn to play part inside the app which could of sped up the learning time.

The stories and the puzzles are all very cool and I enjoyed the breakup of monotony of regular game play. No complaints here!

I was tense and riveted to the narrative in general. I pushed my characters at all times to learn what was behind that next door... that next clue... so I could solve the mystery. Like all good mysteries and ghost stories there is a story of tragedy... or some other tale to be unveiled ...and MoM2ndEd is no different. There has been so much care in these stories that is really gives me as a player a real sense of anticipation and excitement.

With all this back and forth, good and bad, frustration and elation, Mansions of Madness is a good game that left me wanting more. It's dichotomy and contradictions beacon me to come forth and play. Yes the game is much too expensive and not worth the $100, but I did have fun. I am just not sure it is worth the price tag in the end. One of my friends stated, "for the money I could of bought the three games, Eldritch Horror, Elder Signs and Arkham Horror for the price of this game and had an almost BETTER time in the Lovecraftian world". This might be an exaggeration, but it has some merit and points out the "Value" of this product. Most people that I know agree that this game is not worth $100.

For many, this might be a game to borrow from a friend and play, because after the 4th scenario it's really finished. Sure the IOS App randomizes the mansions rooms, but in the end you will be facing the same monsters and base story in each scenario.

Good luck and game on!

34 people found this helpful

2,699 total ratings, 469 with reviews

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

Translate all reviews to English

From the United States

Arielle Hacking

This review is for newbies.

Reviewed in the United States on April 22, 2019

Style: Mansions of MadnessVerified Purchase

277 people found this helpful

Helpful

Melissa Salinas

A Spine-Chilling Thriller: Mansions of Madness Board Game Review

Reviewed in the United States on April 18, 2024

Style: Mansions of Madness & Expansion BundleVerified Purchase

Mansions of Madness isn't just a game; it's an immersive journey into the heart of darkness. If you're a fan of Lovecraftian horror and enjoy spine-tingling suspense, this game is a must-have addition to your collection.

What sets Mansions of Madness apart from other board games is its ability to transport players into a world of chilling mystery and intrigue. Set in the eerie universe of H.P. Lovecraft, each scenario plunges you into a haunted mansion or sinister locale, where ancient secrets and eldritch horrors lurk around every corner. As you explore the dimly lit corridors and uncover hidden clues, you'll feel a sense of unease and anticipation that keeps you on the edge of your seat.

One of the game's most impressive features is its use of technology to enhance the gameplay experience. The companion app serves as your guide and storyteller, generating randomized events, controlling enemy movements, and providing atmospheric sound effects that ratchet up the tension to heart-pounding levels. Whether you're facing off against cultists, zombies, or unspeakable monsters, the app ensures that each game feels fresh and unpredictable.

Mansions of Madness is also a game of strategy and deduction. As you and your fellow investigators work together to solve puzzles, decipher cryptic messages, and confront otherworldly threats, you'll need to use all your wits and cunning to survive. With multiple characters to choose from, each with their own unique abilities and strengths, there's no shortage of ways to approach each scenario, ensuring that every game is a thrilling and unpredictable adventure.

In conclusion, Mansions of Madness is a must-have for any horror enthusiast or board game aficionado. Its immersive storytelling, innovative gameplay mechanics, and atmospheric presentation combine to create an unforgettable gaming experience that will haunt your dreams long after the game is over. So gather your courage, dim the lights, and prepare to enter a world of terror and madness like no other.

Helpful

CCrystals121

Game Night Is Going To Rock!

Reviewed in the United States on June 12, 2023

Style: Mansions of MadnessVerified Purchase

I used to play D&D 5e, but could never hone the necessary DM skills to put a game together, so I figured I'd give Mansions of Madness 2nd Edition a try--I just love an immersive RPG /dungeon crawl experience, and this game pulls it off BEAUTIFULLY!

While I am a huge fan of This War of Mine, Waste Knights 2nd Edition, Fallout and similar rpg games, this is the first app driven rpg which I've had the pleasure of experiencing, and I keep wanting to play it again. While the game is intuitive in many respects, you'll definitely need to study the rules and do a few playthroughs during which you write down questions you have, so you can keep notes on what you'll have to share with other players.

For me, I needed straightforward notes on: 1) which skill checks are needed for various actions (Strength Test for Heavy Weapons, Agility for Bladed Weapons, etc) 2)How to use the app during the Mythos Phase when Monsters will spawn and attack you/how Horror Checks are done 3)how to attack monsters using various levels of weapons and spells 4)Understand how Damage and Horror cards function. Once you understand these elements, you're ready to play--Remember, the app times you, and if you're taking too long when taking actions/making decisions, you will risk losing the game--so learn the rules!

Mansions of Madness second Edition is worth the money spent on it, worth the time you invest learning to play it--it is a solid, well crafted story experience which will challenge you and entertain you. If you're unable to read the app text on your phone because it displays too small, download Steam on your laptop, and download the app for free there.

My one complaint about this boardgame, it is that the app doesn't really allow you to go back to look up certain things--if you don't pay attention to some text, don't try to go back or the game will at times restart, asking once again for the investigators being used, while new starting items will be generated. Other than this, I'm loving this game, and can't wait to play it with friends!

11 people found this helpful

Helpful

Rebel

Amazing and Complex Game! Well worth it!

Reviewed in the United States on May 26, 2019

Style: Mansions of MadnessVerified Purchase

This is an awesome game to add to your collection if you are big into co-op games or complex thinking games. This is a very sophisticated game, in the fact that there is decision making, puzzles, cause and effect challenges, and storyline/telling. There are multiple scenarios that come with the purchase. The replay value is very good, as the game changes drastically or every so slightly depending how many players you have or what choices you make. There are expansions as well and I would say they are worth the money. Do note, TONS of pieces and tiles. We used ziplock bags and rubber bands to keep organization, as the box is just a box, not organizer inside. The pieces also are plain and you can paint them with is a cool, but time consuming. So beware of you are an impatience painter. The game takes time to learn, but the “help books” are easy read and have an index, which is helpful for quick rule referencing. Give yourself double the estimated game play the first time, as it takes time to learn the game. Again, this is a great game to add to any gamers collection. Highly recommend it so advise board gamers or if you are into D&D.

5 people found this helpful

Helpful

August

Madness That Keeps You Coming Back

Reviewed in the United States on October 18, 2020

Style: Mansions of MadnessVerified Purchase

First of all the game overall is fantastic. An A+ in theme immersion, and although is app assisted it doesnt take away from the table top experience. Expensive? Yes. However if you're a fan of the chthulu mythos and serious enough about spending the coin then this game is worth it. While the attention to rules detail can be daunting it was one of my first serious gaming purchases and was able to get it down well enough to teach it to newcomers. The rulebook is easy enough to search any questions that may pop up, it's well explained and printed; you just gotta put in the dedication time for this game. My only prominent complaint about this is in the enemy/monster components. If I'm paying close to $100 I expect better quality. Most of the monsters where in good condition however some were very flimsy and bent and didn't hold in their character base. So I have to take the review down a notch for that. Some at home fixing was able to make due. Gameplay is very difficult, it's a game you play to lose the first few time, but that doesnt make it bad just very challenging. Overall a solid 4 star, some components need work though; they only get 3 stars. I would recommend this in a heartbeat though. Great value, great theme and a challenge that's worth it.

Helpful

ron schultz

awesome game

Reviewed in the United States on March 17, 2024

Style: Mansions of MadnessVerified Purchase

whole family loves it. extremely fun to play

Helpful

Leonardo Araque Rodriguez

FANTASTIC

Reviewed in the United States on March 21, 2024

Style: Mansions of MadnessVerified Purchase

Amazing game

Helpful

J. Payne

One of the best boardgames on the market!

Reviewed in the United States on June 21, 2018

Style: Mansions of MadnessVerified Purchase

Fantastic game. A total blast to play. Dying horribly has never felt so fun!

Be forewarned -- the shortest scenario is going to take you close to three hours the first time you play it, because it takes a few playthroughs to get a firm grasp of the rules. Once you get a feel for the game, play times will be closer to the estimates. It's absolutely worth sticking it out, because this game is beautiful, smooth, engaging and entertaining. It's the closest feeling yet to being inside an RPG.

There are several scenarios included with the basic game itself, five or six I think, and each scenario has TONS of elements that change randomly, so you could play the same scenario in back to back games and have entirely different plots, antagonists, layouts, items and conditions of victory. There's no rush to buy any of the expansions; you're not going to run out of game for a long time.

The game CAN be played on a smartphone, but a tablet will make the experience significantly better. Everything is easier to see, and having more room to manipulate the various puzzles is a good thing. I do wish the game came with a hard-copy book of different scenarios to allow play without a smartphone or tablet (like Betrayal at House on the Hill), but I suppose there are just too many variables to properly reproduce in a booklet, and letting the device handle the crunching of numbers and variables does let everyone focus more on the Star Spawn plowing through a wall instead of the effect of two successes on trying to pick the lock on a safe. As such, I'm not docking this game a star, because I think the tradeoff of ease of use vs. offline playability is acceptable and likely for the best.

Very happy with this game, as is my gaming group. It makes for a fun night when nobody has an adventure ready to run, and everybody still gets an RPG experience!

11 people found this helpful

Helpful